PENN STATE NOTES: James Franklin has concerns about possibility of mandated injury reports

  • Big Ten commissioner Jim Delany is in favor of providing weekly injury reports.
  • Delany's comments were made in the wake of a Supreme Court decision on sports betting.
  • Penn State coach James Franklin says he has concerns about making injury information public.

CHICAGO — Penn State coach James Franklin is someone who protects injury information regarding his players with all the zeal of the CIA guarding sensitive government secrets, which is why he has many questions regarding the release of such notifications with the advent of legalized sports gambling.

Penn State head coach James Franklin speaks at the Big Ten Conference NCAA college football Media Days in Chicago, Monday, July 23, 2018. (AP Photo/Annie Rice)

Big Ten commissioner Jim Delany opened up the conference’s football media days Monday by saying he was in favor of providing weekly injury reports, which he referred to as “availability reports,” on a national basis in the wake of the Supreme Court decision  on sports betting.

Franklin said, however, that he was not “looking to do anything to help people in terms of who they’re choosing and who they’re betting on.”

“I’m not really necessarily concerned with helping people make better decisions with things like that,” he said. “I do think obviously they’d like to have some situation where you’re leveling the playing field … about everybody kind of playing by the same rules. The problem is, how are you going to enforce all those things? So one program is doing one thing, another program is doing completely the opposite, and it makes it challenging.

“For us, I want to know what the rules are within our state. I want to know what the rules are nationally. Once I know what those are, then we’ll just work around them, but to be honest with you, besides that, we’re going to educate our players on what they need to be aware of, educate our coaches on what they need to be aware of. But besides that, there will be business as usual for us.”

Delany said an “availability report” is needed regarding injuries, eligibility or a “transgression of one kind or another.”

“I think we need to do that,” he said. “I think we need to do that nationally, and the reason we need to do that is probably with the exception of the home field, the availability of the personnel is critical to people who are interested in gambling legally, or illegally.

“Therefore, when players are unavailable, we should know that. If they’re probable or likely, I don’t have the model code, but I do think it is something that we should do and probably should have done it before, and certainly should do it now.”

Franklin said he will follow the rule if one is established. But if one is not, “then we’re going to keep business as it’s been for a number of different reasons.

“Part of it was gambling, part of it is our players’ health, it’s personal, there’s some [federal] laws when it comes to those types of things,” he said. “And the other thing is, if I tell you, if you have a weakness, why are you going to put your weakness out on the table and let people know what those things are?”

Franklin also expressed concern about how any new gambling-related rules would be enforced, whether each school would be responsible or if the NCAA would do it, and what penalties would be implemented if a school did not comply.

For his part, Delany wants to see college athletics protected under any legalized gambling legislation.

“I think that we would prefer a federal framework that omits college sports from gambling at the state levels,” he said. “If that’s not possible, then there should be some standardization of a framework so that college sports, high school sports, Olympic sports, those categories of sports, receive some additional protection.”


Could Bowen return: Rumors have swirled in recent months that former Penn State linebacker Manny Bowen, who was dismissed in December, might return to the program. Franklin neither confirmed nor denied those rumblings on Monday.

Franklin was asked if Bowen has been added to the roster or if his return was even possible. The coach didn’t entertain the questions.

“We haven’t announced any roster changes,” Franklin said. “We don’t live in a world of rumors and innuendos. If the roster changes, it changes. If it doesn’t, it doesn’t.”

As a refresher: Bowen was suspended prior to the 2017 Rose Bowl for a violation of team rules. The veteran linebacker also missed the final three regular season games of last season before being dismissed, along with wide receiver Irvin Charles, days before the Fiesta Bowl.

Penn State could really use Bowen in 2018. With Jason Cabinda gone, there is a massive hole at middle linebacker to fill. Franklin said Monday that Cabinda’s replacement has to be a “problem solver” and “eraser that’s going to give everyone confidence.” With 21 starts and 137 tackles to his name, Bowen would bring that to Brent Pry’s defense.

But will Bowen get a second chance? Franklin said he’s focused on players currently on Penn State’s roster — and as of Monday, Bowen is not one of them.

“We could bring up probably 30 guys that are no longer on the roster and discuss whether we think they’re back or not,” Franklin said. “I’m more than happy to talk about the guys that are currently on the roster. If we have any changes to the roster — deletions or additions — Kris (Petersen, assistant athletic director for strategic communications) will make announcements when appropriate.”

Temple, PSU in talks about series: Temple and Penn State are in negotiations for a future home-and-home football series, according to a source familiar with the situation.

The source says the games will be played in 2026 and 2027, but did not know if the first year’s game will be at Penn State or Temple. The deal has not been finalized but is expected to be completed.

The two schools last played in 2016 when Penn State earned a 34-27 home win over the Owls. That came after Temple opened the 2015 season with a 27-10 victory over the Nittany Lions. It was Temple’s first win over Penn State since 1941.

Temple has four nonleague games per season while competing in the American Athletic Conference. Penn State has three in the Big Ten. Both teams have their nonconference games scheduled through the 2020 season.

John McGonigal of the Centre Daily Times and Marc Narducci of contributed to this report.