AP Top 25 Takeaways: Veteran QBs Clifford, Nix deliver big
Being a good, but definitely not great, quarterback can be a rough ride in college football.
Good enough to start and be successful, but not good enough to satisfy fans that see only a ceiling they wish was higher.
This is the life that Penn State's Sean Clifford and Oregon's Bo Nix have led, and on Saturday, the veteran quarterbacks proved their worth.
Clifford, in his sixth year with Penn State, deftly guided the 22nd-ranked Nittany Lions through hostile territory and to one of their most impressive nonconference victories in years. Clifford took a lick from Auburn, popped back up and sent Tigers fans home early from Jordan-Hare Stadium. Clifford was 14 for 19 for 178 yards, a rushing touchdown and nary a turnover.
The future at Penn State is five-star freshman Drew Allar. The future looks bright and some Nittany Lions fan are in a rush to get there. But for now, Clifford's the man for Penn State coach James Franklin, who appears to have surrounded the 24-year-old with the best set of weapons the team has had in in several years.
Freshman running backs Nick Singleton and Kaytron Allen (who combined 174 yards and four touchdowns) have resuscitated a Penn State running game that has been dormant for two years.
“The ability to be more balanced and take pressure off the passing game has been really important for us,” Franklin said.
Add some talented pass-catchers, and Clifford can be both game-manager and playmaker.
The record says Penn State is in the same place it was last year after three games: 3-0, with a close road win to open the Big Ten season and victory against Auburn. An injury to Clifford halfway through the Iowa game last year sent Penn State into a spiral. This team feels different.
Meanwhile, Auburn went through two quarterbacks who combined for four giveaways that buried the Tigers. Who knew how much Auburn would miss Nix?
The five-star recruit who started most of the Tigers' games the last three seasons had plenty of highs and lows on The Plains, a mix of the memorable and regrettable.
He jumped into the portal after last season and landed at Oregon. Good choice.
Two weeks removed from being embarrassed by top-ranked Georgia, the 25th-ranked Ducks looked very much like the Pac-12 contender they were expected to be in a decisive victory against BYU.
Nix threw two touchdown passes and ran for three scores against the Cougars. The last Oregon quarterback to do that: Heisman winner Marcus Mariota in 2014.
“One of my past coaches told me that pressure is a privilege, and so I’ve really taken that to heart, and there’s nothing more true in my opinion,” Nix said. “When you have a lot of pressure it means that people believe in you, people believe you can do it, or you wouldn’t have pressure at all.”
The Ducks were so badly outclassed by Georgia in Atlanta on Labor Day weekend it was tempting to wonder whether new coach Dan Lanning and his staff might be in over their heads. And there were plenty of Ducks fans wondering if Nix was really the best they could do a quarterback with former blue-chipper Ty Thompson on the bench.
Since that 49-3 loss, the Ducks have scored 111 points. Against BYU, a team that went 5-0 against the Pac-12 last year and beat Baylor last week, Nix had the Ducks up 38-7 in the third quarter.
Neither Clifford nor Nix are going to be players the draftniks debate after the season. And there will likely be moments this season when their fans still long for the next big thing.
But they were more than good enough Saturday.
GOING, GOING ...
Now that Nebraska has moved on from Scott Frost, who's the next coach to be fired?
Auburn's Bryan Harsin has seemed like a short-timer since last winter, when boosters decided to fish for a reason to fire him after just one season. The coup didn't work, but it has been apparent that Harsin has little support.
If there was a path to surprisingly successful season that saved Harsin's job, that's probably gone now. Auburn next dives into Southeastern Conference play: Can Harsin survive back-to-back road games against No. 1 Georgia and No. 20 Mississippi in mid-October?
Speaking of Ole Miss, the Rebels beat Georgia Tech and coach Geoff Collins 42-0.
Collins is in Year 4 of a rebuild that figured to be tricky after the Yellow Jackets ran the option under Paul Johnson, but has completely failed to launch.
Georgia Tech is probably not the type of school that's going to pull the plug this early. At this rate, though, it's going to be tough to play out this season. Georgia Tech has UCF next week, No. 23 Pitt after that.
Lastly, Herm Edwards' tenure at Arizona State seems to heading toward an ugly conclusion after the Sun Devils lost 30-21 at home to Eastern Michigan, the first Mid-American Conference team to beat a Pac-12 team.
Arizona State (1-2) opens conference play against No. 14 Utah, No. 7 USC and Washington.
AROUND THE COUNTRY
Appalachian State is must-see TV. This week: The Mountaineer Miracle ... App State's foil last week, No. 24 Texas A&M, bounced back with a victory against No. 13 Miami. A quarterback switch didn't do much to boost the Aggies' offense, but Miami kept malfunctioning in the red zone. The next three weeks for A&M: No. 10 Arkansas, at Mississippi State, at No. 2 Alabama. ... The Pac-12 got a lot more interesting this weekend, especially in the Pacific Northwest. After Oregon's victory, Washington and Michael Penix Jr., took out No. 11 Michigan State. The transformation of the Huskies' offense under first-year coach Kalen DeBoer and Penix, the Indiana transfer, has been remarkable ... We might have been too quick to call Florida quarterback Anthony Richardson a Hesiman contender after Week 1. He struggled again and the Gators were fortunate to escape USF. ... The first game for Nebraska post-Frost could not have gone much worse. No. 6 Oklahoma scored more points in Lincoln than it ever has in a rivalry that dates back more than a century. ... After 179 minutes of football this season, No. 1 Georgia permitted its first touchdown. Brock Bowers and the Bulldogs crushed South Carolina. ... No idea just how good No. 4 Michigan is after the Wolverines outscored Colorado State, Hawaii and UConn 166-17. Maybe Maryland can give Michigan something close to a game next week. Same can be said for unbeaten Minnesota (3-0) having outscored weak opposition 149-17 ... The Gophers trounced Colorado on Saturday. The Buffaloes are making a strong case for being the worst team in Power Five. ... The first FCS team to beat a Power Five opponent this season is Southern Illinois. The Salukis came in 0-2 and dropped Northwestern, which has lost two straight since beating Nebraska in Ireland. ... A week after the Sun Belt registered three Power Five road wins, South Alabama and Old Dominion had two more on their sights. But UCLA and Virginia both kicked walk-off field goals to avoid the upsets. ... The Sun Belt raided Conference USA in the offseason, but C-USA got a little revenge Saturday going 3-0 in nonconference games. That included Rice beating Louisiana to end the longest active winning streak in FBS at 15 games. ... This week's big upset came from the American Athletic Conference: Tulane beat Kansas State of the Big 12 to go 3-0 for the first time since 1998 ... March Madness in September: Kansas, Duke, Syracuse and Indiana are all 3-0. The Blue Devils and Jayhawks play in Lawrence, Kansas, next week.