Littlestown teacher now facing trial in student sex case

Liz Evans Scolforo

A Littlestown Area School District music teacher who is a York County resident is facing trial in Adams County Court on charges he sexually assaulted two high school students, physically assaulted a third and made unwanted sexual comments to a fourth, whom he also is accused of inappropriately touching.

On Wednesday, Nicholas Andrew Oaster waived his right to a preliminary hearing before District Judge Daniel Bowman.

Nicholas Oaster

Outside the Adams County courtroom, Oaster declined comment to The York Dispatch.

His defense attorney, Terry McGowan, also declined comment.

Formal court arraignment is set for July 10, court records state.

Oaster, 32, of 17 Frock Drive in Penn Township, is free on $50,000 bail, charged with involuntary deviate sexual intercourse, four counts of unlawful contact with minors, sexual assault, two counts of corruption of minors, three counts of indecent assault and five counts of harassment.

He was the music and chorus teacher for the high school and the district's middle schools, officials said.

According to Littlestown Police, the investigation began after a Littlestown Senior High School student went to the school principal April 7 and said Oaster had assaulted another student, adding that the student "fear(ed) for the safety of future students and did not want to see them hurt in the same way," according to charging documents.

School administrators began their own investigation in addition to alerting police, documents state.

Police allege Oaster assaulted and harassed the girls over a six-year period, starting in 2011 and ending in April of this year.

Littlestown Area School District placed Oaster on paid administrative leave April 10, the Monday after the allegations came to light, according to an online letter to parents written by Superintendent Christopher Bigger.

The allegations: Oaster physically forced one girl to perform oral sex on him in October 2012 after luring her into the band office, despite her attempts to fight him off and despite the fact she was crying, charging documents allege.

The girl was 17 at the time and told investigators the contact started with Oaster giving her "consolation" hugs after she and her boyfriend broke up, documents state. But after about a week, Oaster started fondling her buttocks when he hugged her and also would touch the girl's breasts, both under and over her clothing, police allege.

Documents state Oaster on another occasion put his hands inside the girl's pants in a classroom and fondled her genitals, despite the fact that the girl was bent over and trying to pull his hands out of her clothing.

He once ripped her bra while forcefully touching her breast, police allege.

'Over 100' assaults: The girl told investigators she would push him away when he inappropriately touched her but that Oaster continued to sexually assault her "a few times a week" until she graduated several years ago. She estimated there were "over 100" separate assaults, which happened in the band office, the music library, Oaster's office and Oaster's high school classroom, according to charging documents.

Another student told police Oaster sexually harassed her since she started attending the high school, making comments about her taking off her clothes and sitting on his lap, documents allege.

He asked her, "Are you ready to have sex with me?" and once commented about leggings she was wearing by saying, "they would look better on my bedroom floor," according to documents, which state Oaster asked her to have sex with him on numerous occasions.

Pushed into cabinet? A third girl interviewed by authorities reported that Oaster made rude comments to her that were couched as jokes and once threw a water bottle at her face, documents state. The girl said that in late February, Oaster pushed her into a filing cabinet, causing a scratch on her arm, police allege.

A fourth girl reported that Oaster made inappropriate comments about having sex with her when she saw him daily for chorus class in the spring of 2015, according to police.

Charging documents allege Oaster knew the girl took self-defense classes and would ask her to show him those tactics as he put her in chokeholds.

Police: Hanover-area teacher abused 4 girls

The girl said Oaster kept doing it several times a day even though it made her very uncomfortable, documents state. She also said Oaster became more aggressive and more hostile as "he kept getting away with it."

The fourth girl, who was 17 at the time, said Oaster touched her buttocks four or five times in June 2015 as she was helping him carry musical instruments or supplies from the school, documents state.

"Victim ... related the first time she thought it might have been an accident, but when she turned around ... Oaster would look at her and 'smirk,'" documents state.

— Reach Liz Evans Scolforo at or on Twitter at @LizScolforoYD.