Owner of Conewago cemetery guilty of theft in Ohio

  • Theodore Martin, one of the owners of Suburban Memorial Gardens, pleaded guilty to theft in Ohio.
  • His wife, Arminda Martin, pleaded late last week.
  • The two were charged last year on allegations related to Suburban Memorial Gardens.
  • That case was taken over by the Office of the Inspector General.

The husband-and-wife owners of a Conewago Township cemetery have both pleaded guilty to theft related to one of their Ohio cemeteries.

Arminda Martin, 47, and her husband, Theodore "Ted" Martin, 54, also own Suburban Memorial Gardens at 3875 Bull Road in Conewago Township.

Suburban Memorial Gardens

On Monday, Oct. 23, Theodore Martin pleaded guilty to 14 counts of theft related to Fairview Memorial Park, a cemetery he and his wife own in Delaware County, Ohio, according to the Delaware County Prosecutor's Office.

On Friday, Oct. 20, Arminda Martin pleaded guilty to 15 counts of theft in the case. With their pleas, the couple waived their rights to an appeal.

According to the Delaware County Sheriff's Office, the two had scammed "dozens, if not hundreds, of innocent victims who have paid for burial plots, vaults and head stones for loved ones but never received anything."


Theodore Martin. Photo courtesy Delaware County, Ohio, Sheriff's Office.

According to a report from the Delaware Gazette, Theodore Martin admitted to taking money for items at the cemetery but never delivered the items.

Many of the counts the couple pleaded to were against elderly people, according to the prosecutor's office.

The Martins were charged in York County in 2016 with theft related to Suburban Memorial Gardens, but the local charges were withdrawn, and the Office of the Inspector General took over the case.

Arminda Martin. Photo courtesy The Delaware County Prosecutor's Office.

Ohio: Ohio officials charged the Martins earlier this year.

The Martins were indicted in Delaware County, Ohio, which charged the two with one count of engaging in a pattern of corrupt activity and more than 40 counts of theft, according to the Delaware County Prosecutor's Office.

The couple were then indicted on additional charges, replacing the original charges, in June, the prosecutor's office said. 

According to the prosecutor's office, 67 people said they had paid the couple for their services at Fairview Memorial Park in Delaware, Ohio.


"They describe purchasing items such as grave markers, grave plots and vaults, all of which were never provided after payment," Delaware County Prosecutor Carol O'Brien wrote in a Facebook post.

Fairview Memorial Park remains under the care of a receiver, Columbus-based attorney A.C. Stripe, according to a report from the Delaware Gazette. 

The prosecutor's office said the couple will be sentenced Dec. 8, and restitution will be decided at that time.

The couple also faces charges in Portage County, Ohio, related to another cemetery they own, Grandview Memorial Park, in Ravenna.

According to court documents, the couple used money given for services at the cemetery for personal uses. Their trial in that case is scheduled for Dec. 11, according to court records.

Tax evasion: In October 2016, the two were sentenced to a year in federal prison for tax evasion and were ordered to pay more than $300,000 in restitution, according to court records.

On Jan. 27, 2016, in federal court, the two pleaded guilty to the felony of attempting to evade federal taxes, records state.

They failed to report about $786,500 they received from operating their cemeteries between 2008 and 2011, according to a news release from the U.S. Attorney's Office.

Locally: Last year, Northern York County Regional Police filed 32 sets of theft and related charges against each of the Martins in January and February, and the couple were arraigned on those charges in March, court records state. Those charges alleged that the two accepted money from customers for grave markers but did not complete their purchases.

In May 2016, police withdrew all of the theft charges because the investigation was turned over to the federal Office of the Inspector General, police said at the time.

Some of the grave markers paid for by clients but never purchased by the Martins were for military veterans, Northern York County Regional Police Lt. David Lash said at the time. Because the Office of Veterans Affairs pays for a portion of veterans' grave markers, the Office of the Inspector General became involved, police have said.

Lash said the Martins' guilty pleas and sentencing for tax evasion are separate from the Inspector General's investigation into the alleged thefts of money earmarked for grave markers.

On Thursday, Oct. 26, Lash said the department was still occasionally receiving calls about the cemetery. He said anyone who has previously reportedly their case to them should call the Office of the Inspector General to report alleged theft.

People who have not reported their allegations can call Northern York County Regional Police and they will be directed where to go from there.

Aside from their tax-evasion case, the Martins have not seen any additional charges in Pennsylvania since the investigation was handed to the Office of the Inspector General.

Lash said the department could refile the local charges if nothing comes from the Office of the Inspector General, but he said there are no plans to do so yet.

"It's their investigation at this point," he said.

Original allegations: In early February 2016, four people told police they'd ordered grave markers at Suburban Memorial Gardens, but that after weeks of questioning the owners, their markers were never placed, according to court documents. Customers alleged the Martins cashed the checks they were given but never placed the markers.

By late February 2016, many had come forward to police, alleging some of their orders had never been placed. Some of these dated back to 2005, police said.

The amount of money people alleged the Martins had taken from them varied significantly in the documents. Some stated the Martins had taken as little as $143, while one man told police the Martins stole nearly $8,000 from him, according to documents.

— Reach Christopher Dornblaser at cdornblaser@yorkdispatch.com or on Twitter at @YDDornblaser.