2 charged in Feb. robbery at Dover Turkey Hill

Christopher Dornblaser

Northern York County Regional Police have charged two men in a February robbery at a Dover Township Turkey Hill, where one man allegedly pointed a pellet gun at a clerk to get money, according to a release.

Isaiah Nathaniel Toomey, 19, of 2300 Derry Road, West Manchester Township, and Trey Dejour Cuthrell, 21, of 1632 W. Market St., West York,are charged with robbery, theft, receiving stolen property and conspiracy to commit robbery, according to police.

Trey Cuthrell

Police say the two men entered the Turkey Hill on 2820 Carlisle Road at around 1:20 a.m. on Feb. 1, and one of them pointed a black semi-automatic handgun at the clerk and demanded money. Toomey was found to be the one who threatened the clerk with the weapon, which was discovered to be a pellet gun, police said. The clerk gave them money in a bag while Cuthrell went behind the counter and removed cigarettes from the display, according to police.

Isaiah Toomey

Police: Armed robbery at Dover Turkey Hill

The men fled on foot south on Carlisle Road, according to police.

The investigation is ongoing; anyone with information is asked to contact police at (717) 292-3647.

— Reach Christopher Dornblaser at