The knight was kidnapped from the sidewalk in front of Castle Toys and Games in Beaver on Monday afternoon. Acting on a tip, police say they found it in an apartment in nearby Chippewa Township.
Police say the men thought the theft was a good idea at the time, but are now reconsidering and hoping to do some community service to make amends. Police have yet to identify the men.
The Playmobil figurine is worth about $1,000, though store owner Linda Lyden says it's priceless to customers who like to have their picture taken with it.